Positive Workplace Deviance vs the Governance Chastity Belt

According to popular history, when European knights left for the holy land during the crusades, they fitted their wives with a chastity belt to guarantee their fidelity. The devices were a crude method to enforce chaste behaviour because the Knights did not trust their wives while they were on their holy tour of duty. It is unlikely that chastity belts indeed prevented any lonely woman from expressing her natural urges. We can apply this concept also to management and the rise of governance.

Organisational Chastity Belt

The chastity belt is making a comeback—and not only with contemporary connoisseurs of erotic bondage. The Global Financial Crisis has driven an increased focus on governance in organisations. More risk management, more red tape, more creativity stifling procedures—more paper chastity belts. These procedural chastity belts serve the same purpose as the medieval metal versions. Chastity belts are a tool that replaces trust with a forced power dynamic.

A lack of trust in the ability of people to make the right decisions on your behalf often leads to a perceived need for corporate chastity belts.

Procedural chastity belts, just like their physical counterparts, are not foolproof methods to ensure chaste behaviour in wives and managers. Employees will circumvent any device that replaces trust when the motivation and the reward for deviance outweigh the risks.

The key to unlocking the regulatory chastity belt is to look at your processes and start to unravel them. Procedures should enable people to achieve objectives. They should not be the final word on how employees do their job. The people that write these procedures are after-all not all-knowing gods of management.

Positive Workplace Deviance

Lucid managers allow for positive workplace deviance, and they enable the employees to make their judgement on how to best achieve goals, instead of using the bondage of red-tape.

Deviant behaviour has a bad name for obvious reasons. We all know people who behave negatively in the workplace, even resorting to bullying or harassment. Positive workplace deviance is not about embracing your Machiavellian tendencies but more about breaking unwritten rules to progress organisational objectives. To think outside the box, to use a cheesy metaphor, requires you to bend the rules to shift reality.

A popular meme to express this idea is “not to give a fuck“. This somewhat crude popular wisdom does not imply that you can rampage your way through your workplace with caring about the consequences. Positive workplace deviance is the subtle art of crafting your niche within your organisation or your industry.

A Lucid Manager always asks why unwritten business rules exist and seek inspiration in playing little thought experiments to test the boundaries of the traditions within an organisation. Those trying to use positive workplace deviance to can find inspiration from the great Frank Zappa who famously said:

“Without deviance from normality, there can be no progress.”

Frank Zappa: Without deviane from normality there can be no progress". Positive workplace deviance

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.